Manzanos Wines USA
8 Thanksgiving Leftovers Wine Pairings for the Day After (2026)
← Back to Blog
PairingsBy Manzanos Wines USA

8 Thanksgiving Leftovers Wine Pairings for the Day After (2026)

Day-old turkey deserves a new bottle. Eight leftover dishes, from the cranberry sandwich to cold pie, and the wines that make each one feel like a fresh meal.

Americans cook roughly 46 million turkeys every Thanksgiving, and according to the Natural Resources Defense Council about 200 million pounds of turkey meat get thrown out over the holiday week. Most of that waste happens on Friday and Saturday, when the fridge is full, the novelty is gone and nobody wants a third plate of the same dinner.

The fix is not a new recipe. It is a new bottle. The meal you reinvent on Black Friday has a different flavor profile than the one you served on Thursday: more cranberry, more mayo, more cream sauce, more chili flakes. The wine should change with it.

Here are eight day-after dishes and the bottles from our portfolio that make each one feel like a fresh meal, not a rerun.

Key Takeaways

  • Cranberry is the loudest flavor in most leftovers, so reach for wines with real acidity.
  • Creamy casseroles want texture (a round Chardonnay or a silky Tempranillo), not big tannin.
  • Spicy reinventions like turkey chili or enchiladas need ripe fruit and moderate oak.
  • Day-old pie is the best excuse of the year for a light, low-alcohol Moscato d'Asti.
  • Every bottle below is in stock in the U.S. and ready to ship to all 50 states.

What Wine Goes With Thanksgiving Leftovers?

The short answer: fresher and brighter than what you poured on Thursday. Reheated turkey loses some of its moisture, cold turkey is lean, and the sides that survive (stuffing, cranberry sauce, sweet potatoes, green bean casserole) get mixed together in sandwiches, hashes and bakes. That combination of sweet, tart and salty rewards wines with acidity and fruit. Heavy, oaky reds tend to flatten it.

If you already planned Thursday with our Spanish wine pairings for every Thanksgiving course, think of this as part two.

8 Day-After Dishes and the Wines That Revive Them

1. The Turkey-Cranberry Sandwich: Bruce Jack Reserve Sauvignon Blanc

The sandwich is the national leftover. Turkey, stuffing, a thick swipe of cranberry sauce and mayo on soft bread. Cranberry brings tartness and sugar at once, so the wine needs enough acid to match it.

Bruce Jack's Reserve Sauvignon Blanc from South Africa's Western Cape does exactly that: lively green apple, fig and nectarine, with the cape gooseberry character of the country's cool southern coastal vineyards. It scored 90 points and won a Michelangelo 2023 Gold Medal. Serve it at 45 to 50°F so the fruit stays crisp against the cold turkey.

2. The Cold Leftover Plate: Las Campanas Rosé

Some people skip the sandwich and eat a cold plate standing at the counter: sliced turkey, a spoon of cranberry, a few roasted Brussels sprouts. That is rosé territory. Las Campanas comes from the oldest winery in DO Navarra, founded in 1864, and the brand pioneered Spanish rosé production in the 1950s.

The Garnacha rosé is pale pink, with fresh red fruit, citrus and a finish that recalls blood orange. Delicate enough for white meat, bright enough for the cranberry.

Cranberry sauce served with sliced leftover turkey, sweet potato and a glass of rosé wine

3. Turkey Pot Pie: Siglo Tempranillo

Pot pie is the most comforting thing you can do with leftovers: turkey, carrots, peas and gravy under a buttery crust. It needs a red with fruit and structure, but nothing that fights the cream.

Siglo Tempranillo, the Rioja in the famous burlap-wrapped bottle, earned 92 points from both Wine Enthusiast and James Suckling. Its red fruit cuts through the gravy without overwhelming a lean meat. It is also one of the easiest Spanish reds to find in U.S. stores.

4. Turkey Soup or Creamy Turkey Chowder: Las Campanas Chardonnay

The carcass becomes stock on Saturday morning and soup by dinner. A clear broth with herbs wants something light. A creamy chowder wants texture. Las Campanas Chardonnay from Navarra covers both: tropical, white and stone fruit on the nose, fresh and silky on the palate, at a moderate 12.5% alcohol. It also took a Mundus Vini Silver medal.

5. Turkey Tetrazzini or Mushroom Pasta Bake: Duchessa Lia Nebbiolo d'Alba

Turkey, mushrooms, a parmesan cream sauce and pasta, baked until the top browns. Earthy, savory and rich. This is where Piedmont shines. Nebbiolo is a grape known for high acidity, red cherry and rose notes, and an earthy streak that loves mushrooms. Duchessa Lia's Nebbiolo d'Alba brings that Piedmont profile in a more approachable style than a Barolo, which makes it a smart Saturday-night red.

6. Turkey Chili or Turkey Enchiladas: Las Campanas Garnacha

By Saturday many households turn the last of the turkey into something spicy. Chili powder, cumin and a little heat call for ripe fruit and soft tannin, never a tannic monster that makes the spice burn.

Las Campanas Garnacha (92 points, Best Buy, Wine Enthusiast) shows black and ripe fruit, violets and a touch of vanilla and chocolate from oak aging. Round and mellow, it is built for exactly this kind of dish.

7. Stuffing Waffles and the Leftover Brunch: Bruce Jack Moveable Feast Red Blend

Press leftover stuffing into a waffle iron, top it with turkey, gravy and a fried egg, and you have the most fun meal of the weekend. The herbs in the stuffing are the key, and that is where Moveable Feast comes in. The name fits the dish, and so does the wine: a blend of Syrah, Malbec, Touriga Nacional, Barbera, Tannat and Tinta Barocca from South Africa's Overberg Highlands, with mulberry, blackberry and plum woven with garden herbs and fynbos floral notes, matured 26 months in barrel.

8. Day-Old Pie: Duchessa Lia Moscato d'Asti

Pumpkin, pecan or apple pie eaten cold from the dish on Friday night deserves its own pour. Duchessa Lia Moscato d'Asti won a Gold Medal with 95 points at the Decanter World Wine Awards 2026. It is aromatic with wisteria, acacia and fresh fruit, gently sweet and only 5.5% alcohol, which makes it a light end to a long weekend. Serve it well chilled.

Is Red or White Wine Better With Leftover Turkey?

Both work, and the deciding factor is the sauce, not the bird. Cold turkey with cranberry or mayo favors whites and rosés with acidity, like the Bruce Jack Reserve Sauvignon Blanc or the Las Campanas Rosé. Warm dishes with gravy, cream or spice open the door to lighter and medium-bodied reds: Siglo Tempranillo, Nebbiolo d'Alba or Garnacha. Save the most structured reds for leftover roast beef or ham.

Bonus: Leftover Prime Rib or Glazed Ham

If your table had beef or ham alongside the turkey, this is the moment for Rioja's top tier. Manzanos Gran Reserva Rioja 2015 scored 95 points from Wine Enthusiast, with dried prunes, licorice, clove, tobacco and cedar over silky tannins. The Manzanos Reserva Rioja 2018 earned 93 points from Wine Enthusiast and is a natural match for warm roast beef sliders. Both come from the Fernández de Manzanos family, five generations of winemaking in Rioja and Navarra since 1890.

For Retailers and Restaurants: The Post-Thanksgiving Window

The days after Thanksgiving are a quiet opportunity on the wine floor. Shoppers come back for "something for the leftovers" and for the weekend's gatherings, and a simple shelf talker or a by-the-glass special built around the day-after menu gives them a reason to trade into a new bottle. Our portfolio spans more than 600 wines rated 90 points or higher, and everything above is in stock in the U.S., ready to ship to all 50 states.

If you buy for a store, a restaurant group or a distributor, work with a Spanish wine importer that keeps U.S. inventory on hand, or become a Manzanos distributor in your state.

Frequently Asked Questions

What wine goes well with a Thanksgiving meal?

Fresh, fruity, flexible wines: crisp Sauvignon Blanc, dry rosé, Tempranillo, Garnacha and lighter Pinot Noir. They handle the mix of sweet, savory and tart dishes on one plate better than heavy, oaky reds.

Do you pair red or white wine with turkey?

Either one. Turkey is lean and mild, so the side dishes and sauces decide. Cranberry and mayo point to a white or rosé with acidity; gravy, cream and spice point to a medium-bodied red.

What to do with Thanksgiving Day leftovers?

Turn them into new dishes instead of reheating the same plate: sandwiches, pot pie, soup, tetrazzini, chili, enchiladas or stuffing waffles. The USDA advises eating refrigerated leftovers within three to four days, or freezing them for later.

How long does an open bottle of wine last after Thanksgiving?

Most still wines keep two to five days with the cork back in and the bottle in the fridge. Our guide to how long wine lasts after opening covers each style.

Find These Wines Near You

Look for our brands at Costco, Total Wine & More, Albertsons, Spec's, BevMo!, Binny's, Hy-Vee, Rouses, Sedano's, Lunds & Byerlys and Haskell's, depending on your state. Use Find Our Wines to locate a store near you, or browse our full portfolio.

Manzanos Wines USA is the premier importer of premium wines from Spain, Italy, Chile, South Africa, and France, serving all 50 US states through our nationwide distributor network. Learn more at manzanoswinesusa.com.

Please enjoy responsibly. Must be 21+.

Manzanos Wines USA is a Spanish wine importer in the United States: Rioja and Navarra wines from our own family wineries, in stock in the U.S. and ready to ship to all 50 states.

#Thanksgiving leftovers#wine pairing#turkey sandwich#Bruce Jack#Siglo#Las Campanas#Duchessa Lia#Moscato d'Asti#Rioja
M
Manzanos Wines USA
Five generations of Spanish winemaking — now importing premium wines from across the world to all 50 US states.

Discover Our Wines

Explore the full Manzanos Wines USA portfolio — premium wines from Spain, Italy, Chile, France, and South Africa, delivered to distributors and restaurants across America.

Explore Our Wines